Bookmark and Share
Printer Friendly

Stanley: The Chutzpah of Obama’s Jewish Critics

Martine Kaplan — August 3, 2009 – 4:29 pm | Israel | Obama | Stop the Smears Comments (2) Add a comment

NJDC Chairman Marc Stanley wrote an op-ed in the Jerusalem Post criticizing President Barack Obama’s Jewish critics, particularly Aluf Benn for his op-ed in the New York Times last week. Stanley sets the record straight on several popular criticisms of Obama’s Middle East policy.

An excerpt:

What may speak louder than Obama’s words are his actions. As the ink of Benn’s op-ed was drying, the president sent Secretary of Defense Robert Gates, National Security Advisor Gen. Jim Jones and Middle East Special Envoy George Mitchell to talk with their Israeli counterparts. They spoke about issues ranging from US policy against Iranian nuclear proliferation to the continuing strategic partnership between our governments. We now see numerous media reports reflecting the reality that this administration will couple any settlement deal with sharp pressure on the Arab world to normalize relations with the Jewish state.

NO ONE can credibly claim Obama and his administration are not talking to Israel. The reality is the administration is not only talking with Israelis, it is intensely collaborating and communicating with it- in person. In fact, Obama spoke with Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu face-to-face about settlement growth. This administration is talking with Israel about the wide range of policies on which we agree - and those precious few areas on which we disagree.

To read the full piece, click here.

Comments

Obama on Israel | August 4, 2009 – 1:18 am

Whether or Obama is or is not “pro-Israel” is just a matter of semantics…since the beginning of his term he has made many mistakes in his handling of Israel related policy.
Also, I think this article does a fair job exposing those faults
http://www.jpost.com/servlet/Satellite?cid=1248277936580&pagename=JPost/JPArticle/ShowFull

Non-Western Jew | August 5, 2009 – 2:28 am

Sure, he is talking, but the problem is in what he is saying. Obama is trying to be even-handed in this, but as a result, he is not looking at the root of the problem. Israel has always wanted peace and has been willing to give and give and give. But the Arab world is stubborn, rooted in their hatred for Jews.

I also resent the fact that a bunch of comfortably-living Western Jews involved in your organization and others have the chutzpa to tell Israel what to do. Just because we are Jewish does not give us the right or the legitimacy to speak on behalf of all Jews or Israel. Living in Israel as a Jew is very different than life in the West. It’s so conceited of Western Jews to speak on behalf of Israel and lobby for Israel to make concessions when they have never lived under the constant threats that most Israeli Jews experience everyday. Yes, we are all Jews, but don’t you dare compare your comfortable life to that of Israeli Jews who live under existential threat everyday.

Western Jews need a little humility. Either support Israel or take a step back. But don’t lobby for Israeli concession when it’s the Israelis and not you who will have to experience the life-threatening repercussions!

Add a Comment
Note: This form does not support AOL's browser. If you are currently using AOL's browser, please use a major browser, such as Firefox, Safari, Chrome, or Internet Explorer.